What Is Mistaken Identity? Strategies for Proving Innocence

Mistaken identity is a defense in criminal law that claims the actual innocence of the defendant.

What Is Mistaken Identity?
What Is Mistaken Identity?

It attempts to undermine evidence of guilt by asserting that any eyewitness to the crime incorrectly thought that they saw the defendant, when in fact the person seen by the witness was someone else.

Proving Mistaken Identity

To prove that it was a case of mistaken identity, the defense can use several strategies. One of the most effective strategies is to establish an alibi.

If the defendant has a valid alibi that places them somewhere else at the time of the alleged crime, and witnesses can verify the alibi, this may be all it takes to prove mistaken identity.

Another strategy is to use DNA testing. DNA evidence is much more accurate today, and it is much more accessible, affordable, and quick.

If DNA evidence plays any role in a criminal investigation, this may be all it takes to exonerate a wrongfully accused suspect.

In general, the defense must demonstrate that the witness indeed wrongfully identified the defendant as the offender.

This can be done by questioning both the memory and perception of the witness.

The prosecution in a criminal case must prove the guilt of the accused beyond a reasonable doubt, so the defense must convince the jury that there is reasonable doubt about whether the witness actually saw what they claim to have seen, or recalls having seen.

Burden of Proof

The burden of proof in a criminal case is on the prosecution.

The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the alleged crime.

In some cases, an accused individual can simply do nothing and allow a prosecutor’s case to fall apart due to lack of evidence, but this is very rare.

Most mistaken identity cases arise from photo arrays and lineup identification during the initial phases of a criminal investigation.

For example, the police may ask a crime victim for a description of his or her attacker and then gather suspects that fit the provided description.

This may entail showing photographs of known criminals or having suspects appear for lineup identification.

Due to the inherent failings of human memory and the effect that trauma can have on an individual, it is not uncommon for a victim to mistakenly identify his or her attacker, potentially placing blame on an innocent person.

How does the defense prove that it was a case of mistaken identity?

To prove that it was a case of mistaken identity, the defense can use several strategies. One of the most effective strategies is to establish an alibi.

If the defendant has a valid alibi that places them somewhere else at the time of the alleged crime, and witnesses can verify the alibi, this may be all it takes to prove mistaken identity.

Another strategy is to use DNA testing.

DNA evidence is much more accurate today, and it is much more accessible, affordable, and quick.

If DNA evidence plays any role in a criminal investigation, this may be all it takes to exonerate a wrongfully accused suspect.

In general, the defense must demonstrate that the witness indeed wrongfully identified the defendant as the offender.

This can be done by questioning both the memory and perception of the witness.

The prosecution in a criminal case must prove the guilt of the accused beyond a reasonable doubt, so the defense must convince the jury that there is reasonable doubt about whether the witness actually saw what they claim to have seen, or recalls having seen.

What are some other defenses in criminal law?

There are many different types of criminal defenses that can be used in a court of law. Here are some of the most common ones:

1.Innocence

This Défense is raised when the defendant did not commit the crime and the prosecution has to prove every element of the crime charged against the defendant beyond a reasonable doubt.

2.Self-defense

This defense is used when the defendant claims that they acted in self-defense.

The defendant must prove that they acted in self-defense and that the force they used was reasonable under the circumstances.

3.Insanity

This defense is used when the defendant claims that they were legally insane at the time of the crime.

The defendant must prove that they were legally insane at the time of the crime and did not know that their actions were wrong.

4.Duress

This defense is used when the defendant claims that they were forced to commit the crime under threat of harm or death.

The defendant must prove that they were under duress and that there was no reasonable way to avoid committing the crime.

5.Entrapment

This defense is used when the defendant claims that they were induced to commit the crime by a law enforcement officer.

The defendant must prove that they were induced to commit the crime and that they would not have committed the crime otherwise.

6.Statute of limitations

This defense is used when the prosecution has waited too long to bring charges against the defendant.

The defendant must prove that the statute of limitations has expired and that they cannot be charged with the crime.

7.Alibi

This defense is used when the defendant claims that they were somewhere else at the time of the crime.

The defendant must prove that they were somewhere else and that they could not have committed the crime.

Conclusion

Mistaken identity is a serious issue in criminal law. It can lead to wrongful convictions and can ruin the lives of innocent people.

It is important to understand the strategies that can be used to prove mistaken identity, and the burden of proof that is on the prosecution.

If you or someone you know has been accused of a crime, and you believe that mistaken identity may be a factor, it is important to seek the advice of an experienced criminal defense attorney.

 

Leave a Comment